Is this a joke I missed?

There's 2, how many options do you need?

They're way too big, and A2 is too small. If you're 5'10 195 lbs there's really not an option for you.
The A2H should be the height of A2 with the weight of A3

Yea A2H will be a bit big for ya. Have you tried the Kitsune A2? I have teammates with your dimensions who wear it. Worst case if you're particularly wide or long for your height or weight, sticking to cold wash and hang dry should mitigate the (pretty minor) shrinkage. These are rather thoroughly preshrunk so they wont shrink much, even if you do break the rules and machine dry your Gis.

Yeah I have the Kitsune Heroes in A2 and the pants are too small in the seat. The jacket is great but I'm going to have to buy pants from someone else to use with it.
I feel like I'm a very average size so it's strange.

So buy a different gi

Never thought of that

A3H

210-245 lbs
way too big

@Jesse, give the A3H a try. If it doesnt fit, we'll take it back for a full refund. I know it sounds odd, but the A2H is actually wider than the A2H. Shoyoroll mad this particular fit this way a few years ago and since it was already established, several other brands that use A3H have a similar fit (presumably because the original A2H was significantly wider than a standard A2). If you need to return it, mention that George authorized a return on the BJJHQ wall and I'll vouch for it with the BJJHQ CS team.

Definitely

Yeah.

Yeup

Yep.

Yes sir

Yes, mam

Ohhhhh yeah it is ;-)

:-P